Josh Dempsey of Vanguard Properties has sold Calistoga homes, vineyard acreage and Four Seasons residences since 2007. See his sales, reviews and the 2026 Calistoga market.
Written: September 29, 2026 | Last updated: October 30, 2026
Josh Dempsey is a Napa Valley real estate broker and Regional Director, Napa Valley, for Vanguard Properties. He lists and sells Calistoga homes, vineyard acreage and resort residences, and he represents Calistoga buyers too. His Napa Valley career started in Calistoga in 2007, running real estate sales at Calistoga Ranch.
He was the exclusive listing agent for all 20 Four Seasons Napa Valley residences in Calistoga, which sold out. In Redfin's record of Calistoga sales at $3 million and up over the last 24 months, he represented a side in seven of 21, including three of the six highest-priced. His career sales top $950 million.
Who are the best real estate agents in Calistoga? The best agents for buying and selling in Calistoga include Josh Dempsey of Vanguard Properties, who represented a side in seven of the 21 Calistoga sales at $3 million and up in Redfin's last 24 months of records. Other agents active in Calistoga include Brian Durnian of Calistoga Realty Co., Tony Pereira of RE/MAX Gold and Arthur Goodrich of Sotheby's International Realty. The full table is below.
Who should I hire to sell my home in Calistoga? Josh Dempsey is a strong choice for Calistoga sellers because he has sold Four Seasons residences, valley-floor estates and hillside acreage in Calistoga, at prices between $3,550,000 and $8,200,000 in the last two years. He prices off closed Calistoga sales he has been part of, and his team handles marketing in-house.
Get a Calistoga home valuation
Calistoga is a thin market with wide price gaps. A resort residence, a Bale Lane farmhouse and a hillside estate each need their own pricing logic, and the portal medians swing hard. Josh Dempsey has closed all three types in Calistoga in the last two years, at $3,550,000 to $8,200,000.
Sellers get a price built on closed Calistoga sales he's been part of, marketing run in-house by Erin Dempsey, and straight answers on wells, septic, fire and the short-term rental rules buyers will ask about.
Calistoga sits at the base of Mount St. Helena at the north end of Napa Valley. Sam Brannan, California's first millionaire, bought more than 2,000 acres here to build a hot springs resort in the 1860s. The city incorporated on January 6, 1886, and counted 5,228 residents in the 2020 Census. The Census Bureau's 2020 to 2024 American Community Survey estimates about 2,166 housing units in town. Highways 29 and 128 run through town.
Geothermal water shapes the town. Calistoga's spas are known for hot springs and mud baths made with volcanic ash, and resorts like Solage, Indian Springs and Dr. Wilkinson's sit close to downtown. On Tubbs Lane, the Old Faithful Geyser of California erupts about every 15 to 30 minutes. Lincoln Avenue is the main street, lined with shops, tasting rooms and restaurants.
A Calistoga real estate specialist prices and sells homes in a town where a resort villa, a valley-floor farmhouse and a hillside estate each follow different rules. The work includes explaining the short-term rental ban, well and septic requirements, fire hazard zones and agricultural preserve limits before a buyer asks. It also means knowing which Calistoga buyers want a turnkey resort residence and which want land and vineyards. Local knowledge shows up in the price, the disclosure package and the timing of the listing.
Calistoga's housing splits into a few types. In town, older homes and newer single-level houses sit on city water and sewer, close to Lincoln Avenue. Along Bale Lane, Larkmead Lane and the Silverado Trail, valley-floor homes sit among vineyards on one to six acres. In the hills, Mountain Home Ranch Road, Diamond Mountain and Franz Valley offer estates on 10 acres or more.
Then there's the Four Seasons Napa Valley residential community on Lawley Lane and Palisades Place. The resort opened in November 2021. Its 20 residences are one- and two-story villas designed by O'Bryan Partnership and Erin Martin, each with two primary suites, an owner's wine cellar and a two-car garage. See the Four Seasons Napa Valley residences in Calistoga page for details.
The Tubbs Fire started on October 8, 2017, off Highway 128 and Bennett Lane in Calistoga and burned 36,807 acres. The Glass Fire started on September 27, 2020, burned 67,484 acres in Napa and Sonoma counties and destroyed 1,528 structures, CAL FIRE reports. Calistoga was evacuated in both fires. The Glass Fire also destroyed Calistoga Ranch, where Josh's valley career began.
CAL FIRE's updated hazard maps put about 51 percent of the city in a Fire Hazard Severity Zone, including 213 acres rated Very High on the northeast side along the Silverado Trail, the Calistoga Tribune reported in May 2025. The city adopted the maps into Municipal Code Section 2.12.050 in 2025. Where a parcel falls in more than one zone, the higher rating covers the whole parcel. Stricter fire-resistant building rules for new construction in those zones were set to start in January 2026.
Redfin rates Calistoga's Fire Factor as moderate and says all of its properties carry some wildfire risk over the next 30 years. Buyers ask about insurance early here. Sellers who gather their policy history, defensible space records and any fire-hardening upgrades before listing give buyers fewer reasons to wait.
Calistoga Joint Unified School District runs Calistoga Elementary School and Calistoga Junior/Senior High School. The district office is at 1520 Lake Street. More on the town is in Josh's Calistoga community guide.
Josh has three active Calistoga listings and one pending listing. Prices are list prices.
| Address | Area | Price | Status | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 21 Lawley Lane | Four Seasons Napa Valley, Calistoga | $6,900,000 | Active | A 2021 single-level residence with 4 bedrooms, 5 baths and 3,370 sq ft on about half an acre, one of the largest homesites in the Four Seasons residential community. |
| 4189 Silverado Trail | Calistoga | $4,795,000 | Pending since October 2026, co-listed | A 2005 estate with 4 bedrooms, 5 baths and 4,826 sq ft on 1.38 acres, reimagined by Kirsten Bennett Interiors, with views across Three Palms Vineyard toward Diamond Mountain. |
| 1015 Bale Lane | Calistoga | $2,400,000 | Active | A 1954 ranch farmhouse with 3 bedrooms and 1,907 sq ft on 1.96 level acres at the St. Helena border, with a producing well, an approved six-bedroom septic system and vineyards in front and behind. |
| 4500 Silverado Trail | Calistoga | $1,000,000 | Active | 4.8 acres with olive and citrus groves and hand-laid stone walls, 2.5 miles from downtown Calistoga. Landscape architect Jack Chandler chose the site for his own residence. |

See every current property on Josh's Calistoga and Napa Valley exclusive listings page.
Zillow credits Josh with 34 Calistoga sales, and the tables below show the public sales he has featured. These sales carry Calistoga addresses in ZIP 94515. Sales closed in the last 24 months come first, newest to oldest, followed by earlier sales by price.
| Address | Area | Price | Sold | Side | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Silverado Trail, off-market listing | Calistoga | $4,295,000 | Announced September 2026 | Listing side | An off-market Calistoga sale Josh announced on Instagram on September 29, 2026, with details kept confidential. |
| 12 Palisades Place | Four Seasons Napa Valley, Calistoga | $6,500,000 | January 2026 | Both sides | A 4-bedroom residence of 3,334 sq ft. Josh represented both the seller and the buyer, and the Press Democrat listed it as the top Calistoga sale recorded that week. |
| 4222 Mountain Home Ranch Road | Calistoga | $8,200,000 | January 2026 | Buyer side | An award-winning 2018 home with 4 bedrooms and 5,572 sq ft on 11.9 acres, with tennis and bocce courts, a pool, guest quarters and a wine cellar. |
| 4 Palisades Place | Four Seasons Napa Valley, Calistoga | $5,300,000 | October 2025 | Both sides | A 2021 residence with 3 bedrooms, 3.5 baths and 2,496 sq ft, sold 32 days after it listed. Josh represented both the seller and the buyer. |
| 10 Palisades Place | Four Seasons Napa Valley, Calistoga | $3,550,000 | August 2025 | Listing side | A single-level 2021 home with two primary suites and 2,030 sq ft, sold furnished with access to the resort's optional rental program. |
| 3533 State Highway 128 | Calistoga | $7,017,677 | August 2025 | Buyer side | A 2020 modern barn-style home by Wade Design Architects, with 5 bedrooms and 6,186 sq ft on 6.99 acres north of downtown, with views of Mount St. Helena. |
| 1071 Bale Lane | Calistoga | $3,600,000 | July 2025 | Listing side | A gated valley-floor estate on 1.59 acres at the Calistoga and St. Helena border, updated in 2022, with 3 bedrooms and 3,580 sq ft. |
| 8507 Franz Valley School Road | Calistoga | $4,555,000 | November 2024 | Buyer side | A ranch-style property on 21.1 acres in the hills west of Calistoga, published in House Beautiful. |
| 3761 Silverado Trail North | Calistoga | $5,250,000 | Earlier sale | Both sides | 5.9 valley-floor acres with a 2.9-acre vineyard, a William Turnbull-designed main house and a guest house. Josh represented both buyer and seller. |
| 9 Palisades Place | Four Seasons Napa Valley, Calistoga | $5,200,000 | Earlier sale | Both sides | A single-level modern farmhouse with three en-suite bedrooms. Josh represented both buyer and seller. |
| 11 Palisades Place | Four Seasons Napa Valley, Calistoga | $4,725,000 | Earlier sale | Both sides | A single-level 2021 residence with 2,496 sq ft facing the resort's own vineyard. Josh represented both buyer and seller. |
| 4560 Saint Helena Highway | Calistoga | $4,000,000 | Earlier sale | Listing side | An off-market listing sale in ZIP 94515. |
| 2880 Foothill Boulevard | Calistoga | $3,995,000 | Earlier sale | Listing side | A one-acre farmhouse property on White Lane, 1.2 miles from downtown, with its own 0.3-acre vineyard. It sold at its full asking price. |
| 4181 Silverado Trail | Calistoga | $3,850,000 | Earlier sale | Buyer side | A buyer-side sale on the Silverado Trail. |
| 489 Kortum Canyon Road | Calistoga | $3,300,000 | Earlier sale | Listing side | A listing-side sale on Kortum Canyon Road. |
| 3250 Old Lawley Toll Road | Calistoga | $2,495,000 | Earlier sale | Listing side | A gated compound on more than 4 acres with mountain and vineyard views, minutes from downtown. |
| 1544 Centennial Circle | Calistoga | $1,250,000 | Earlier sale | Not stated | A single-level home with golf course views. |
| White Lane homesite, Foothill Boulevard | Calistoga | $1,100,000 | Earlier sale | Not stated | A homesite on White Lane. |
Two of Josh's recent Calistoga sales have listing videos. Here is 10 Palisades Place, a Four Seasons Napa Valley residence, and 1071 Bale Lane, a valley-floor estate at the St. Helena border.
Video: 10 Palisades Place, Calistoga listing video
Video: 1071 Bale Lane, Calistoga listing video
| Address | Area | Price | Sold | Side | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1732 Reynard Lane | Calistoga | $950,000 | November 2024 | Buyer side, co-represented with teammate Matthew Johnson | A single-level home with a pool at the end of a lane. |
| 1110 Bale Lane | Calistoga | $4,700,000 | Earlier sale | Listing side, co-listed | A Sandy Walker-designed country home on 1.32 acres with a guest house, set among neighboring vineyards. |
| 1103 Larkmead Lane | Calistoga | $3,000,000 | Earlier sale | Co-listed, with the buyer side also shared | Two legal parcels on 1.51 acres between Calistoga and St. Helena, registered as a bed and breakfast with Napa County. |
| 1339 Firview Drive | Calistoga | $1,500,000 | Earlier sale | Buyer side, co-represented | A craftsman home with views of the Palisades. |
| 2277 Mora Avenue | Calistoga | $1,325,000 | Earlier sale | Co-listed | A 1.91-acre valley-floor parcel sold with approved plans by Signum Architecture. |
| Address | Area | Price | Sold | Side | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 963 Silverado Trail | Calistoga | $7,200,000 | Earlier sale | Team sale | Represented by team agent Matthew Johnson. A one-acre property with a 1920 home. |
The full record is on Josh's Calistoga and Napa Valley sold properties page.
| Property type | Sample Calistoga sales | Price range of those sales |
|---|---|---|
| Four Seasons Napa Valley residences | 4, 9, 10, 11 and 12 Palisades Place | $3,550,000 to $6,500,000 |
| Valley-floor estates and farmhouses | 1071 Bale Lane, 1110 Bale Lane, 2880 Foothill Boulevard, 3761 Silverado Trail North | $3,600,000 to $5,250,000 |
| Hillside and rural acreage | 4222 Mountain Home Ranch Road, 8507 Franz Valley School Road, 3533 State Highway 128 | $4,555,000 to $8,200,000 |
| Land and homesites | 2277 Mora Avenue, White Lane homesite on Foothill Boulevard | $1,100,000 to $1,325,000 |
Josh has sold Calistoga property off market more than once. The table lists the sales he announced on Instagram, and dates are shown only for sales within the last 24 months.
| Address | Area | Price | Details |
|---|---|---|---|
| Silverado Trail, off-market listing | Calistoga | $4,295,000 | Listing side, announced September 2026. Josh kept the details confidential. |
| 4560 Saint Helena Highway | Calistoga | $4,000,000 | Listing side. His earlier reel said the new off-market listing went into contract before he had a chance to share anything. His sale post thanked the owners of the family property, calling them "great stewards for this legacy property." |
Josh also introduced an off-market Calistoga compound on 6.59 acres, just 1 mile from downtown Calistoga, in an earlier Instagram post. The caption gave no address.
Momentum in a busy stretch. In an August 16, 2025 Instagram post, Josh reported over $20,000,000 closed in a two-week stretch that summer, including 3533 State Highway 128 at $7,017,677 and 1071 Bale Lane at $3,600,000 in Calistoga, plus two St. Helena sales. He added:
"If you get my newsletter, you read my reflection on the current market, which noted a growing sense of momentum in the Napa and Sonoma luxury markets this past month."
Josh Dempsey, on Instagram, August 16, 2025
Josh shares his own account of recent work on Instagram (@jdnapavalley) and lists his career on LinkedIn. These are his words and his record, in three points for Calistoga sellers.
Difficult properties can sell quietly. On September 29, 2026, Josh posted a SOLD graphic for an off-market listing on the Silverado Trail in Calistoga at $4,295,000. He wrote that the details have to remain quiet, and he described the property this way:
"A special property with a lot of unique challenges that we were able to overcome along the way."
Josh Dempsey, on Instagram, September 29, 2026
Patience on a hard sale pays off. A client who sold vacant land in west Napa County through Josh described how he handled offers they did not like. The review is from July 2018 and covers a sale in Oakville, not Calistoga, but it shows how Josh approaches a slow, difficult listing.
"He did not push us to sell upon receiving unsatisfying offers nor to drop our asking price - rather he encouraged us to wait for the right buyer which he believed would come along."
Michael K., sold vacant land in Oakville, Zillow, July 2018 (Josh Dempsey on Zillow)
Calistoga Ranch relationships last. In an October 20, 2026 Instagram reel, Josh said an old friend from Calistoga Ranch called for help with an acquisition. The deal closed in Napa, and he wrote:
"We ended up closing escrow at a smoking good deal on a property I'd admired since before the estate was even built. It always goes back to the land!"
Josh Dempsey, on Instagram, October 20, 2026
A long record in the same community. LinkedIn lists Josh as Director of Real Estate at Calistoga Ranch, where he oversaw sales and marketing of the Lodges at Calistoga Ranch. It also lists him as Exclusive Listing Agent at Four Seasons Napa Valley in Calistoga between November 2016 and February 2021, and his Instagram keeps a story highlight for Four Seasons Napa Valley.
Talk to Josh Dempsey about selling in Calistoga
These agents are active in the Calistoga market. Each row gives the agent's current brokerage and one public fact we could verify in November 2026, such as RealTrends Verified sales volume or where the agent is based. The table states facts, not opinions, and the order is not a ranking. Josh Dempsey is listed first because this is his page.
| Agent | Brokerage | Verified fact (source) |
|---|---|---|
| Josh Dempsey | Vanguard Properties | No. 4 by volume and No. 3 by sides in St. Helena, $80.81 million across 22 sides (RealTrends Verified 2026, 2025 data) |
| Brian Durnian | Calistoga Realty Co. | Based at a Calistoga brokerage, with an active listing in September 2026 (MLSListings) |
| Tony Pereira | RE/MAX Gold | The Tony Pereira Team ranked No. 9 by volume in Napa, $12.26 million across 20 sides (RealTrends Verified 2026, 2025 data) |
| Arthur Goodrich | Sotheby's International Realty | No. 9 by volume in St. Helena, $32.42 million across 10 sides (RealTrends Verified 2026, 2025 data) |
| Darlene Brissard | Calistoga Realty Co. | Based at a Calistoga brokerage, with an active co-listing in September 2026 (MLSListings) |
| Sandy Tucker | NextHome In The Valley | Works from the brokerage's Calistoga office (NextHome agent profile) |
| Robert Pursell | Compass | Napa-based Compass agent (Compass agent profile) |
| Tim Hayden | Compass | St. Helena-based, $16.25 million across 4 sides in St. Helena (RealTrends Verified 2026, 2025 data) |
| Joel Toller | Coldwell Banker Brokers of the Valley | Works from the brokerage's St. Helena office (Coldwell Banker profile) |
Calistoga is a small market, and a few big closings move its numbers a lot. Read the figures below together, not one at a time.
| Measure | Latest figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Median sale price, 3 months ending August 2026 | $954,368, down 57.1% year over year | Redfin |
| Median sale price per sq ft | $596, down 51.5% | Redfin |
| Average days on market | 52 days, compared with 61 a year earlier | Redfin |
| Sale-to-list ratio | 98.7%, up 8.0 points | Redfin |
| Homes sold above list price | 20.0% | Redfin |
| Homes sold in August 2026 | 5, compared with 6 in August 2025 | Redfin |
| Single-family closed sales, Q2 2026 | 9, compared with 7 in Q2 2025 | Sotheby's International Realty |
| Single-family median sale price, Q2 2026 | $1 million, down 28% from $1.39 million in Q2 2025 | Sotheby's International Realty |
| Home value index, August 31, 2026 | $1,065,148, down 1.0% year over year | Zillow |
| Median list price, September 29, 2026 | $2,313,000 | RealTrends |
| Active inventory, September 29, 2026 | 47 listings | RealTrends |
| Median days on market for active listings | 105 days | RealTrends |
| Active listings with a price cut | 30.5% | RealTrends |
The median sale price fell by more than half, but Zillow's home value index, which tracks every home rather than the ones that sold, slipped 1.0 percent. The gap points to the mix of homes that closed, with fewer high-end Calistoga sales this summer.
The top of the market is still there. Redfin recorded 21 sales at $3 million and up in ZIP 94515 over the past 24 months, led by $13,475,000 on Franz Valley School Road and $11,550,000 on Tubbs Lane. Josh Dempsey was on seven of those 21.
Buyers are choosy. The median asking price, $2,313,000, sits far above recent sale prices, active listings wait a median of 105 days, and nearly a third have taken a price cut. Redfin's Compete Score says some Calistoga homes still get multiple offers, and one in five sold above list this summer. Price and presentation decide which group a listing lands in. Josh's guide on how to maximize your Calistoga home value covers preparation in more detail.
Data comes from the Redfin Calistoga housing market report, the Zillow Calistoga home values page, the RealTrends Calistoga market update and the Sotheby's International Realty Calistoga market update, which draws on BAREIS MLS data.
Josh holds a 5.0 rating on Zillow, and his Vanguard Properties Zillow profile shows 134 total sales. His Zillow reviews date between 2017 and 2020. These reviews are by clients tied to Calistoga and Calistoga Ranch.
"Josh was great from start to finish! We would wholeheartedly recommend him to others seeking real estate in Napa Valley. (Josh assisted us in buying a time share at Calistoga Ranch.)"
dblandes2, bought in ZIP 94515, Zillow, July 2018 (Josh Dempsey on Zillow)
"...it was Erin and Josh’s ability to genuinely connect with the interested buyers that created the community of satisfied owners and enabled Olympus to achieve a virtual sellout of the residences in 2013."
Laurie C., Olympus, developer of Calistoga Ranch (Josh Dempsey testimonials)
"We met Josh through Calistoga Ranch where we are owners, allowing us 6 weeks per year in the Napa Valley. He knew we were considering a move from Virginia and were trying to determine where we should land full-time. ... Josh showed us the house that became our home."
Brenda H., Calistoga Ranch owner who relocated to Napa Valley (Josh Dempsey testimonials)
Request your Calistoga home valuation
| Address | Area | Price | Details |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2350 Big Ranch Road | Napa | $13,100,000 | Buyer side, sold October 2026. A 2.35-acre estate surrounded by vineyards with 7,751 sq ft, 7 bedrooms, a guest house and a resort-style pool and spa. |
| 2051 Curry Lane | Napa (Coombsville) | $9,100,000 | An estate on 6.81 acres with a 2.53-acre vineyard. |
| 890 Fulton Lane | St. Helena | $9,000,000 | A farmhouse renovated by Howard Backen. |
| 1500 Wheeler Lane | St. Helena | $7,800,000 | Reported by the Napa Valley Register as the most expensive home sold in Napa County in April 2024. |
| 225 NW Sumac Court | Healdsburg | $6,150,000 | Buyer side. |
Josh started in real estate in 2000 after earning an economics degree at Santa Clara University. He worked in commercial brokerage in Palo Alto, then served as broker of record for a 160-condominium project in Truckee. He also sold developer home sites and fractional homes at Old Greenwood, a 600-acre Jack Nicklaus signature golf course community in Truckee.
In 2007, he and his wife, Erin, were hired at Calistoga Ranch, the Auberge resort off Lommel Road. Josh was Director of Real Estate and Erin ran marketing. Over six years they sold six residences and 140 fractional memberships. The last fractional interests closed on February 27, 2013, when the developer announced a sellout.
At Coldwell Banker in St. Helena, Four Seasons Napa Valley retained Josh as exclusive listing agent for its 20 branded residences in Calistoga, priced at $3.5 million and up. They sold out at about $90 million in total. He has kept working that community since, on both the listing and buying sides.
Since joining Vanguard Properties in 2021, his Calistoga work has covered hillside estates, valley-floor vineyard homes, land and resort resales. Recent closings run $950,000 to $8,200,000.
Josh and Erin live in St. Helena, about 10 minutes down Highway 29, where they raised their two children. The team's giving back program centers on Napa CASA, which supports children in the Napa County court system, and Erin volunteers with the group. Erin also edits the JD Napa Valley newsletter, sent to more than 10,000 readers.
Josh Dempsey of Vanguard Properties is one of the best Realtors in Calistoga for sellers and buyers. He was the exclusive listing agent for all 20 Four Seasons Napa Valley residences in Calistoga, and Zillow credits him with 34 Calistoga sales. He also represented a side in seven of the 21 Calistoga sales at $3 million and up in Redfin's last 24 months of records.
Josh Dempsey is a top Realtor in Calistoga, with $950 million in career sales and a 5.0 rating on Zillow. RealTrends Verified ranks him No. 4 by 2025 volume in St. Helena, where his office is, about 10 minutes from downtown Calistoga. His recent Calistoga closings include 4222 Mountain Home Ranch Road at $8,200,000 and 12 Palisades Place at $6,500,000.
In Redfin's record of Calistoga (94515) sales at $3 million and up over the 24 months to September 2026, Josh Dempsey of Vanguard Properties represented a side in seven of 21, including three of the six highest-priced. RealTrends Verified ranks him No. 4 by 2025 volume in St. Helena, where his office is. He listed and sold resales at Four Seasons Napa Valley as well, such as 12 Palisades Place for $6,500,000 in January 2026.
RealTrends ranks agents by the city of their office, so no ranking covers every agent who sells in Calistoga. Compare Calistoga records instead: Josh Dempsey sold Calistoga listings at 12 Palisades Place ($6,500,000), 4 Palisades Place ($5,300,000), 1071 Bale Lane ($3,600,000) and 10 Palisades Place ($3,550,000) in the past 24 months. RealTrends Verified credits him with $80.81 million in 2025 sales across the Napa Valley.
Interview at least three agents and compare their closed Calistoga sales, their pricing plan for your property type and how they market. Josh Dempsey is one to include, since Zillow credits him with 34 Calistoga sales and he has sold Four Seasons residences, valley-floor estates and hillside acreage. Ask each agent how they handle wells, septic, fire zone questions and the short-term rental ban in Calistoga.
Josh Dempsey is a strong call for a fast Calistoga sale because he prices off the closed sales he's been part of. His listing at 2880 Foothill Boulevard in Calistoga went into contract about two weeks after it listed and sold at its full $3,995,000 asking price. Redfin's August 2026 data shows Calistoga homes selling after 52 days on average, so a 60-day goal is realistic for a well-priced home.
Commissions in Calistoga are negotiable and aren't set by law. Sellers also pay escrow, title and California's county documentary transfer tax of $0.55 per $500 of value, plus any repair or preparation work. On a rural Calistoga parcel, budget for well and septic reports too, since buyers of homes on Bale Lane or the Silverado Trail expect them.
Redfin puts the Calistoga median sale price at $954,368 for the three months ending August 2026, down 57.1 percent from a year earlier. Zillow's Calistoga home value index, which tracks all homes rather than those that sold, was $1,065,148 on August 31, 2026, down 1.0 percent. The gap tells Calistoga sellers that fewer high-end homes closed, not that values fell by half.
Redfin reports that Calistoga homes sold after 52 days on average in the three months ending August 2026, faster than 61 days a year earlier. RealTrends showed a 105-day median for active Calistoga listings on September 29, 2026, with 30.5 percent carrying a price cut. Pricing right at launch is the biggest lever a Calistoga seller controls.
Some are. Redfin shows 20.0 percent of Calistoga homes sold above list in the three months ending August 2026, with an average sale-to-list ratio of 98.7 percent. Josh Dempsey's Calistoga listing at 2880 Foothill Boulevard sold at its full asking price.
Yes, and Josh Dempsey does it. His off-market Silverado Trail listing in Calistoga sold for $4,295,000, which he announced on Instagram on September 29, 2026 while keeping the details confidential. An off-market sale suits a Calistoga property with unusual challenges or an owner who wants privacy.
Inside Calistoga city limits, renting a home for 30 consecutive days or less is prohibited under Municipal Code Chapter 17.34, adopted by Ordinance 778 on November 18, 2025. That changes the buyer pool for in-town Calistoga homes. Four Seasons Napa Valley residences, such as 10 Palisades Place, came with an optional resort-run rental program, which Josh Dempsey explains to buyers and sellers in that community.
Josh Dempsey was the exclusive listing agent for all 20 Four Seasons Napa Valley residences in Calistoga, which sold out, and he has handled resales since. His Calistoga resales include 12 Palisades Place for $6,500,000 in January 2026 and 10 Palisades Place for $3,550,000 in August 2025. He represented both sides on 12, 11, 9 and 4 Palisades Place, and he is listing 21 Lawley Lane at $6,900,000.
Josh Dempsey handles both halves of a Calistoga downsize. He has sold large Calistoga estates, including 4222 Mountain Home Ranch Road (5,572 sq ft on 11.9 acres) on the buyer side for $8,200,000. He also knows the smaller single-level options in Calistoga, such as the Four Seasons residences on Palisades Place and in-town homes near Lincoln Avenue.
Josh Dempsey can help heirs and trustees sell Calistoga property, including rural homes with wells, septic systems and older permits that need clear disclosure. He has sold Calistoga homes built as early as 1930, such as the 1103 Larkmead Lane property he co-listed. He works from St. Helena, about 10 minutes down Highway 29 from downtown Calistoga, which helps out-of-town heirs who can't be on site.
Calistoga draws second-home buyers for its hot springs, spas, wineries and a quieter pace at the top of Napa Valley. In-town Calistoga homes can't be rented short term, while the Four Seasons Napa Valley residences offered an optional resort rental program. One Calistoga Ranch owner wrote that Josh Dempsey helped them settle in the valley full time after leaving Virginia.
Calistoga was evacuated during the 2017 Tubbs Fire, which started off Highway 128 and Bennett Lane, and again during the 2020 Glass Fire, which burned 67,484 acres. Redfin rates Calistoga's Fire Factor as moderate and says all of its properties carry some wildfire risk over 30 years. Calistoga sellers help their sale by gathering insurance history, defensible space work and any fire-hardening upgrades before listing.
Many homes outside central Calistoga run on private wells and septic systems, including Josh Dempsey's listings at 4189 Silverado Trail and 1015 Bale Lane. Buyers will ask for well output and water quality tests and a septic inspection. In town, the City of Calistoga supplies water, and its Kimball Reservoir provides about one third of the city's yearly demand.
Josh Dempsey has sold Calistoga vineyard and acreage homes, including 3761 Silverado Trail North, a 5.9-acre property with a 2.9-acre vineyard and a William Turnbull house, where he represented both sides for $5,250,000. He represented the buyer of 3533 State Highway 128 on 6.99 acres for $7,017,677 in August 2025. Farmland around Calistoga falls under the Napa County Agricultural Preserve, created in 1968 to protect the valley floor.
Yes. Josh Dempsey is listing 4500 Silverado Trail in Calistoga, 4.8 acres with olive and citrus groves, for $1,000,000. He also co-listed 2277 Mora Avenue, a 1.91-acre Calistoga parcel with approved Signum Architecture plans, and sold the White Lane homesite on Foothill Boulevard.
Josh Dempsey was No. 4 on The Real Deal's Napa Valley list of the top five brokers by deal volume in August 2026, based on RealTrends data. He is a top 5 producing agent in Napa Valley two years in a row, Top Agent in Napa Valley 2022 per Realist, and a San Francisco Magazine Top 100 agent. The Press Democrat also reported his 12 Palisades Place sale in Calistoga as the top sale of its week in February 2026.
Calistoga Joint Unified School District runs Calistoga Elementary School and Calistoga Junior/Senior High School. The district office is at 1520 Lake Street in Calistoga.
Yes. Calistoga sits at the north end of his territory, which also covers St. Helena, Yountville, Napa and the rest of Napa Valley, plus Sonoma and Sonoma County. He works from the Vanguard Properties office at 1345 Railroad Avenue in St. Helena, about 10 minutes from downtown Calistoga.
Call (707) 637-6123 or email [email protected]. You can also request a Calistoga home valuation on his website, joshuadempsey.com.